Anna Hazare foretold that August 15th, 2011, India’s Independence Day, would be dwarfed in relevance by August 16th

Tuesday, August 16, 2011 ·

As Anna Hazare and the Congress government duke it out, the real loser is the anti-corruption fight itself.
Post image for Losing the Anti-Corruption Plot

Losing the Anti-Corruption Plot

Anna Hazare foretold that August 15th, 2011, India’s Independence Day, would be dwarfed in relevance by August 16th, when he would begin another fast-unto-death in Delhi. His target: the government draft of the Jan Lokpal Bill – which excluded the Prime Minister and high judiciary from a proposed ombudsman’s purview – and, more broadly, corruption itself. He was right, but not in the way that we expected.

On the morning of Tuesday 16th, Hazare and fellow activist Arvind Kejriwal were detained by police as they left their Delhi residence on the way to begin the fast. Over a thousand further supporters of the Hazare-led anti-corruption movement, including prominent activists Kiran Bedi and Prashant Bhushan, were being held in Chhatrasal Stadium up until the time of writing on Tuesday afternoon. As yet, there is no word on when they will be released.

I have written previously that I do not support Hazare’s cause, or his methods. His proposed solution to corruption in India addresses the symptoms of corruption but not the root cause; it is another piece of legislation on top of countless others that have been twisted and turned to suit whoever has the power to wield them. A Lokpal figure or committee has the potential to become corrupt itself, and whatever boon it offers to an increasingly agitated population will be short-lived.

However, Hazare’s delusions were nothing compared to the concretely unconstitutional, utterly condemnable act on the law’s part in detaining him and his (apparently peaceful, according to reports) supporters. In this case, there is no grey area: the law and constitution of India do not provide for the arrest of a person who threatens to stop eating, let alone a person who seeks to protest the government.

Congress leader Ambika Soni removed the government from the equation: “The police is not under any political influence. They are working independently.” This, to me, seems very difficult to believe. Hazare is a major figure in Indian activism and has in the past six months gained millions of followers in his fight against corruption. It would be fair to say that at present he is India’s best-known activist, especially given the constant comparisons with Gandhiji he is accorded in newspapers and on television. It follows that the government would surely keep a handle on all of his movements, and any police body would seek governmental approval before going so far as to arrest him.

Still, whether the decision to detain Hazare and his supporters was made from up high or on the ground – and in either case, Delhi Police remain in servitude to and an instrument of the Indian government – it remains an unreasonable and over-zealous act. It sets a dangerous precedent for future protests and how they will be dealt with. In effect, those who detain Hazare attempt to brush his movement aside rather than actually deal with it – a quick fix as inadvisable in stopping the movement as Hazare’s own Lokpal Bill is in weeding out corruption. What’s more, it has actually led to much more attention for Hazare and his principles than had he been allowed to fast.

This fact was not lost on Hazare, and his statement upon arrest showed that he had prepared well in advance to be arrested. It also showed that his delusions extend far beyond the Lokpal’s effectiveness. “The second freedom struggle has begun,” he declared, in reference to Gandhiji’s long fight against the Raj. As he urged supporters across the nation to peacefully court arrest and get themselves detained, he said, “there should be no place left in jails in India to accommodate any more persons.”

Hazare, then, also possesses delusions of grandeur and of anarchy in addition to his misguided legal propositions. Gandhiji fought for freedom from a foreign power; Hazare seeks merely to alleviate corruption in a freely self-governed republic. Neither he nor his struggle are nearly as important or influential as Gandhiji’s Satyagraha, or even the recent uprisings in North Africa and the Middle East. As for his cry for “no place left in jails”, it would be a deeply frustrating shame for a revolution to begin over such a misguided principle. It would call to mind an argument between spouses where one party goes off on a trivial tangent and from there the other takes sharp offence and escalates the row, while the real issue gets lost.

Because that is the real loser today: the broader anti-corruption movement itself. Legislative economic reforms have been widely touted (see Nitin Pai and Vivek Dehejia) as having the potential to reduce corruption; replacing existing laws surely offers a better option than piling more laws on top. But we now have on our hands a situation where a weak and ineffective solution was proposed, which ultimately led to an abuse of democratic power. Corruption will continue unabated as the rest of this episode plays out, a sideshow that became the main event. I can only hope that the saga ends before it descends into greater abuses of power, or into violence.

0 comments:

Categories

news (270) entertainment (150) technology (89) USA (75) world (59) hollywood (47) lifestyle (38) 2010 (37) Business (35) download (28) movies (27) trends (25) photo (23) sports (21) video (21) HollywooD Movies.. (17) Latest News (16) tv show (14) HinDi DubbeD Movies (12) latest issues (12) science (12) actress (10) wallpaper (10) moblie (7) Cartoon Movies (6) glamor magazine (6) Moises Roger Mory Lamas (5) cameron winklevoss (5) eduardo saverin (5) sean parker (5) the social network (5) 2009 (4) Washington (4) car (4) design (4) kyle richards (4) mark zuckerberg girlfriend (4) Catfish Movie (3) Jesus Salas (3) John T. Morton (3) Kim Kardashian (3) Tyler Clementi (3) blind side (3) brett favre (3) brett favre jenn sterger (3) camille grammer (3) john lennon (3) john lennon birthday (3) john lennon death (3) kelsey grammer (3) kim richards (3) michael oher (3) michael orr (3) paranormal activity 2 trailer (3) 1995 (2) 1999 (2) 2006 (2) 2007 (2) 2008 (2) 300MB Movies (2) Alejandro Beoutis (2) Amazing and Interesting (2) Ayodhya Verdict (2) Big Bang Theory (2) Dante Navarro (2) Dream Act (2) Global warming (2) Gregorio "Goyo" Rivera (2) Jose Luis Huerta-Sanchez (2) Marla O. Anderson (2) New York (2) Pedro Colón (2) Smallville Season 10 Episode 1 Online Free (2) acjc (2) acjc girls video (2) acjc video (2) acjc video scandal (2) alabama football (2) bill o reilly on the view 2010 (2) brett favre news (2) catfish movie wiki (2) craigslist (2) denisse guerrero (2) divya narendra (2) earthquakes today (2) ebuddy.de (2) endhiran movie review (2) entertainment weekely (2) europass önéletrajz (2) georgia football (2) gia (2) gia marie carangi (2) global logistic properties (2) google trends (2) hidden massage (2) hidden street global (2) hidden street maple global (2) hidden street sea (2) hiddenstreet (2) housewives of beverly hills (2) how did john lennon die (2) intel (2) john lennon s death (2) kim kardashian booty (2) kim kardashian playboy (2) kim kardashian video (2) kim kardashian w magazine (2) leigh anne tuohy (2) los angeles (2) mapletree ipo (2) medical (2) meez (2) michaele salahi (2) msn2go (2) nobel peace prize 2010 (2) ohio state football (2) oklahoma earthquake (2) online sex scandal (2) oregon football (2) paranormal activity (2) psle 2010 (2) real housewives of beverly hills (2) robot movie review (2) saina nehwal (2) sandra bullock (2) saw 3d (2) scandal (2) sensex india (2) sf giants (2) south park (2) tareq salahi (2) the blind side (2) the view (2) ucla football (2) winklevoss (2) 刘晓波 (2) 'Pirates' again plunders overseas box office (1) 'X-Men' mutants weaken with $56M prequel debut (1) 000 on sidewalk (1) 000 troops out of Afghanistan (1) 2010诺贝尔和平奖 (1) 2011. Albums: Gaga's Record Drop-Off (1) 30 Rock Season 5 (1) 30 rock (1) 49ers (1) 50 Cent's (1) 60 minutes (1) 60 minutes overtime (1) 8 New Viral Videos (1) 8x (1) ABC My Generation (1) Aaron Kwok (1) Abbie Boudreau (1) Al-Qaeda's leadership (1) Albert Greenwood (1) Alicia Keys (1) Amazing (1) America (1) America's Best Affordable Hotels (1) America's Most Romantic Restaurants (1) Angel Sanchez (1) Anthony Weiner faces ethics probe as more accusers emerge (1) Appaloosa (1) Apple unveils 'spaceship' campus (1) Application (1) Babri Mosque (1) Baby Formula (1) Bachelor Of Fine Arts (1) Baptist Church (1) Bashar al-Assad (1) Bernadette (1) Big Brother (1) Birthday (1) Bones Season 6 (1) Brain Tumor (1) Buju Banton Trial (1) CIA chief Leon Panetta (1) Cameron Crowe (1) Carrie Fisher Mourn Death (1) Cecil Negron (1) Celebrities in Designer Jeans (1) Channel 7 News (1) Chef Wife (1) Cinnamon Challenge (1) Colorimetric (1) Comedian (1) Congress (1) Cosmopolitan (1) Cupertino Courier (1) D'CalleSon (1) DNS Failure (1) Damon Thomas (1) Dancing police cop in Philippine (1) David Blaine (1) David Copperfield Death (1) David Letterman (1) Death Panels (1) Decision Expected Today (1) Democrats shun Weiner as scandal grows (1) Devils Lake (1) Disastrous sales figures for Lady Gaga (1) Disneychannel.com/halloween (1) Do's and don'ts for fabulous summer feet (1) Dr. Federico Zaragoza (1) Dr. Ricardo Fernandez (1) Eddie Fisher (1) Edie Falco Bashes Reality TV Stars (1) Edie Falco Bashes Reality TV Stars: 'Who The Hell Is Kim Kardashian? (1) Ernesto Chacon (1) Fashion Designers' Icon (1) Fernanda Romero (1) Filipino traffic officer (1) Five worst beach-body foods (1) Gaga's Record Drop-Off (1) Garth Brooks (1) Geo Super (1) German Brain Tumor Association (1) Globally known Bolloywood (1) GoldenEye Hotel and Resort (1) Green River (1) Gwen Moore (1) Hillary Clinton and Angela Merkel (1) Hillary Clinton and Angela Merkel joke about their mutual love of pantsuits (1) How Target stumbled with customers (1) How to Land the Career of Your Favorite TV Character (1) How to land jobs similar to TV characters' (1) Hoyt (1) ICC Awards (1) IFA (1) Inc (1) Interesting (1) Internet (1) Internet Explorer New Issue (1) Iphone (1) James Laforge (1) James O’Keef (1) Japan (1) Jessica Marotta (1) JoCasta Zamarripa (1) Joaquin Phoenix (1) Joe Arpaio (1) Jose Vasquez (1) Juan Mezarina (1) Justin Bieber CSI (1) Kanye West (1) Kate Gosselin (1) Katie Holmes And Tom Cruise (1) Kelly Ayotte (1) Kent Ross (1) Kobari Beef (1) Kodek (1) LONDON (1) Lady Gaga (1) Laura Manriquez (1) Leader's gift to Clinton gets big laughs (1) Leonard seeks catharsis through new book (1) Lisa Rinna Lips (1) Luis V. Gutiérrez (1) MANILA (1) Mad Men (1) Man stumbles across $17 (1) Mark Zuckerberg (1) Markus Klinko (1) Marlboro New Jersey (1) Marymount Manhattan College (1) Melissa Rauch (1) Metro Manila (1) Money (1) More Target Than Tar-zhay? (1) Mt SAC (1) Much Focus on Food and Low Prices (1) Muslim Woman (1) My Generation (1) My Life In and Out of the Ring (1) NBC Universal (1) Nancy Wilson (1) Nbsp (1) New York Times (1) Newest 'X-Men' can't measure up to others (1) Nicole (1) Office Season 7 (1) One Tree Hill Season 8 Episode 2 (1) Oscar Torres (1) Outlaw premiere review (1) PEMRA issued licence (1) PEMRA issues licence to ‘Geo Super’ (1) Pak needs to do more in fight against terrorism: CIA Chief (1) Pakistan Electronic Media (1) Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (1) Panda Express (1) Paralysed stuntman completes London marathon (1) Paris Motor Show (1) Paris Motor Show 2010 (1) Pedro Colon (1) Pirates of the Caribbean (1) President Barack Obama (1) Pressure mounts on Congressman Weiner over sex scandal (1) Princess Beatrice's latest head-piece (1) Princess Beatrice's wacky new hat (1) Ramona Rivas (1) Representative (1) Robert Anthony Malczewski (1) Rodrigo Diez (1) Royal family's quirky derby day hats (1) Ruth Mory (1) Samuel Rodriguez (1) Santa Monica (1) Sarah Brightman (1) September 30 (1) Sergio Villareal Barragán (1) Shilpa Shetty today turns 36 (1) Shopping (1) Similac Recall (1) Smart phones And Tablets (1) Star unleashes anti-Kardashian rant (1) Stephen Colbert and Migrant (1) Steve Jobs makes surprise presentation on new hi-tech Apple headquarters (1) Stranger Tides (1) Sugar Ray Leonard’s shocking revelations (1) Syrian Leader’s Brother Seen as Enforcer of Crackdown (1) Taylor Swift Speak (1) Tea Party (1) Teresa Lewis Execution (1) Test (1) The Apprentice Season (1) The Eddie Kidd Foundation (1) The Gifts on Every Wedding List (1) The Office (1) The Terminal Movie (1) The world's most noteworthy new hotels (1) Tim Kaine (1) Tips to prepare your feet for summer (1) Today Get Free Panda Express (1) Tour Championship (1) Triple-Core Processor (1) True Blood (1) U.S. Senate Armed Services (1) UFC 119 (1) UMOS (1) US senator wants 15 (1) Vh1 (1) Vulture blog (1) Week Ending June 5 (1) Who later Committed Suicide‎? (1) Why smokers gain weight when they quit (1) Wiki (1) Wissam (1) Women in Weiner scandal step forward (1) World Brain Tumor Day (1) World Brain Tumor Day today (1) World's Best New Hotels 2011 (1) X-Men (1) X-Men: First Class (1) Young X-Men (1) Zucker (1) acjc scandal (1) acjc scandal video (1) acjc toilet (1) acjc toilet video (1) admitted to lying (1) alex jones (1) alex smith (1) and Katy Perry (1) angkasawan malaysia (1) anjaana anjaani (1) anjaana anjaani review (1) anjana anjani (1) anjana anjani review (1) ann ward antm (1) antm cycle 15 wiki (1) api unavailable (1) are banks open on columbus day (1) ascuns (1) atlanta braves (1) auburn football (1) aud in usd (1) audience (1) badminton livescore (1) banfield (1) banfield tolima (1) bangalore time (1) bear ulu pandan (1) bill o reilly (1) biosensors (1) bloot (1) body foods (1) bound for glory (1) box office (1) boxing coach (1) braves (1) breast cancer awareness (1) brett farve (1) brett favre sexting (1) brindavanam (1) brindavanam movie review (1) brindavanam review (1) brindavanam reviews (1) brindavanam telugu movie (1) buster posey (1) carly henley (1) carrie prejean (1) charles manson (1) chicago blackhawks (1) chile (1) chile map (1) chile mine rescue (1) chile miner rescue (1) chilean flag (1) chilean miner rescue (1) chilean miners rescue (1) claudia cardinale (1) cnn (1) cold (1) columbus day (1) coming out (1) commonwealth games 2010 badminton result (1) commonwealth games 2010 medal table (1) communications (1) computer system (1) considered significant (1) continues (1) craiglist (1) craigs list (1) craigslist bay area (1) craigslist east bay (1) craigslist sacramento (1) craigslist san jose (1) craigslist vancouver (1) credomatic (1) cregs list (1) crook (1) crook hindi movie (1) crook movie review (1) ctrc (1) cwg (1) dallas cowboys (1) dayna kempson schacht (1) dayna kempson schacht video (1) deadspin (1) debby boone (1) deena nicole cortese (1) deerfield fair (1) degree in business (1) devi (1) dexter episode guide (1) dexter s05e03 (1) dharun ravi (1) diabetes (1) dianna agron (1) disneychannel.pt (1) do dooni chaar (1) do dooni chaar review (1) don larsen (1) don t go breaking my heart (1) dorothy dandridge (1) drugstore checkout (1) dustin moskovitz (1) earthquake in oklahoma (1) earthquake in oklahoma today (1) earthquakes (1) ed schultz (1) eduardo verastegui (1) elclarin (1) elektrona antidaļiņa (1) elephant man (1) elisabeth hasselbeck (1) embraer 175 (1) eminem (1) eminem 60 minutes (1) eminem on 60 minutes (1) emotional phone call (1) endhiran (1) endhiran review (1) endhiran tamil movie review (1) enthiran movie review (1) enthiran review (1) espn (1) espn radio (1) facebook down (1) faye dunaway (1) fight against terrorism (1) finally discovered (1) fingers and toes (1) firstflight tracking (1) flames (1) flamuri kombetar (1) friedensnobelpreis (1) fryeburg fair (1) georgia football schedule 2010 (1) georgia tech (1) germany (1) gia carangi (1) giants (1) gic ipo (1) glee s2e4 (1) glee season 2 episode 4 (1) glee season 2 episode 4 download (1) glee season 2 episode 4 megavideo (1) glee season 2 episode 4 watch online (1) global logistics properties ipo (1) global receipts (1) glp ipo (1) gmail (1) government’s survival (1) gratisspil (1) haunted houses (1) health and fitness (1) health issues (1) helmut kohl (1) hervelvetvase (1) hockey live scores (1) honeyfuggle definition (1) hour-marathon (1) hp ceo (1) hpq (1) huntington (1) huntington disease (1) huntington s disease symptoms (1) icici direct (1) imagine lyrics (1) indomee (1) indomie (1) indomie malaysia (1) indomie recall (1) indomie taiwan (1) infowars (1) infowars money bomb (1) infowars moneybomb (1) infowars-moneybomb (1) installous (1) installous 4.1 (1) installous api unavailable fix (1) installous app unavailable (1) irs forms (1) irs.gov forms (1) is columbus day a federal holiday (1) isabella (1) jacelyn tay (1) jane krakowski (1) japan argentina (1) japan av (1) jenn sterger (1) jerry hall (1) jersey shore episode 10 (1) jersey shore finale (1) jersey shore season 3 (1) john lennon songs (1) jones-begins (1) journal Science (1) joy behar (1) jules undersea lodge key largo florida (1) jules undersea lodge pictures (1) justin bieber u smile (1) justin bieber u smile official music video (1) justin bieber u smile video (1) justin timberlake (1) karen owen (1) karen owen list (1) karen owen powerpoint (1) karen owen ppt (1) karen owen thesis (1) kathleen herles (1) keeping up with the kardashians (1) kelsey grammer divorce (1) kiasu parents (1) kiasu parents psle 2010 (1) knbr streaming (1) kotv (1) latest issues in the world (1) latest reports (1) lavinia longhi (1) leo apotheker bio (1) leona gage photos (1) leong (1) levi's (1) lincecum (1) lines (1) liu xiaobo (1) léo apotheker (1) maison de mark zuckerberg (1) maldives (1) maple leafs (1) mapletree (1) mapletree industrial trust ipo (1) marathon (1) mark salling (1) marketing (1) mayang sari (1) medal tally commonwealth games 2010 (1) mens hockey commonwealth games (1) michigan football (1) michigan state football (1) michigan wolverines (1) michigan wolverines football (1) mike singletary (1) miles austin (1) miner rescue (1) mtv jersey shore (1) muff cabage (1) muff cabbage (1) natural gas (1) nazca (1) nazca lines (1) nc 17 (1) new proton waja (1) newton run 2010 (1) nobel peace prize (1) nobel prize (1) norman earthquake (1) north south highway accident (1) notre dame football (1) o reilly factor (1) o reilly on the view (1) olympus sp 600uz (1) one nation march (1) oregon (1) oregon ducks football (1) oregon ducks football schedule (1) outing (1) pat boone (1) patrick demarchelier (1) paultan (1) pedestrians (1) pedicure (1) perseverance (1) petpet park (1) philadelphia phillies (1) phillies (1) phim cap 3 chau au (1) poha (1) poha npal (1) pop phenomenon emerging (1) powerful intelligence services (1) pregnent (1) prison planet (1) proton (1) proton inspira (1) proton waja (1) psle 2010 maths (1) psle 2010 science (1) psle maths 2010 (1) publicly humiliated (1) puck glee (1) reds (1) reggie bush (1) reinout oerlemans antonie kamerling (1) researchers report (1) rinki chaudhary (1) rinki chaudhry (1) rinky chaudhary (1) rintihan kuntilanak perawan (1) rissa x factor (1) rob kardashian (1) robo review (1) robot review (1) roman polanski (1) rosemary clooney (1) royal head-pieces at the derby (1) rutgers (1) rutgers student (1) sa (1) sa william (1) saina (1) saina nehwal boyfriend (1) saina nehwal cwg (1) saina nehwal family (1) saina nehwal final match (1) saina nehwal hot (1) salahi (1) samsung (1) scientists (1) sean parker napster (1) secret Hillary Clinton loves a good pantsuit (1) sexy diva Shilpa Shetty (1) sf giants radio (1) sgx (1) sharon tate (1) sheikh muszaphar wedding (1) showbiz career (1) sierra kusterbeck (1) sing (1) skins (1) smokers (1) snooki (1) snooki south park (1) south park it s a jersey thing (1) south park its a jersey thing (1) south park jersey shore (1) south park jersey shore episode (1) spice (1) stanford (1) stanford university (1) star driver 輝きのタクト (1) tareq and michaele salahi (1) texas flag (1) texas ou game 2010 (1) the beach house at manafaru (1) the beach house at manafaru maldives (1) the canopy executive condo (1) the canopy yishun ec (1) the luxury spot (1) the real housewives of beverly hills (1) the social network stream (1) tiger (1) tina fey (1) tna (1) tna bound for glory (1) tna bound for glory 2010 (1) told RadarOnline (1) topsfield fair (1) tropical storm danielle (1) tulsa world (1) twin cities marathon 2010 (1) tyler clementi video (1) u of m football (1) u smile (1) uga football (1) uga football schedule 2010 (1) university of michigan football (1) upcoming autobiography (1) usc football (1) usd sgd (1) utah jazz (1) vanessa williams (1) verizonwireless (1) viz graphics (1) vizgraphics (1) wake forest football (1) warren beatty (1) watch jersey shore online (1) watch jersey shore season 2 episode 10 (1) when is columbus day (1) when is columbus day 2010 (1) whoopi goldberg (1) wild wild wet (1) winklevoss twins (1) winner (1) wisconsin football (1) wrestling news (1) www.Chase.com (1) www.proton.com.my (1) xuebao (1) yahoo.com mail (1) zhaoshang (1) スタードライバー (1) 中国海关 (1) 余思敏 (1) 俞夏 (1) 心霊探偵八雲 (1) 童眼 (1) 蔡卓妍 (1) 蔣瓊耳 (1) 輝きのタクト (1) 銀河美少年 (1) 陳偉霆 (1)

You Follow this website

Latest News